The Silence of Polyglots

‘Not speaking one’s mother tongue. Living with resonances and reasoning
that are cut off from the body’s nocturnal memory, from the bittersweet
slumber of childhood. Bearing within oneself like a secret vault, or
like a handicapped child–cherished and useless–that language of the
past that withers without ever leaving you. You improve your ability
with another instrument, as one expresses oneself with algebra or the
violin. You can become a virtuoso with this new device that moreover
gives you a new body, just as artificial and sublimated–some say
sublime. You have a feeling that the new language is a resurrection: new
skin, new sex. But the illusion bursts when you hear, upon listening to
a recording, for instance, that the melody of your voice comes back to
you as a peculiar sound, out of nowhere, closer to the old spluttering
than to today’s code. Your awkwardness has its charm, they say, it is
even erotic, according to womanizers, not to be outdone. No one points
out your mistakes, so as not to hurt your feelings, and then there are
so many, and after all they don’t give a damn. One nevertheless lets you
know that it is irritating just the same. Occasionally, raising the
eyebrows or saying “I beg your pardon?” in quick succession lead you to
understand that you will “never be part of it”, that it “is not worth
it”, that there, at least, one is “not taken in”. Being fooled is not
what happens to you either. At the most, you are willing to go along,
ready for all apprenticeships, at all ages, in order to reach–within
that speech of others, imagined as being perfectly assimilated, some day
–who knows what ideal, beyond the implicit acknowledgment of a
disappointment caused by the origin that did not keep its promise.’

–Julia Kristeva, Strangers to Ourselves (NY: Columbia University Press, 1994,  p.5).  Trans. Leon S. Roudiez

via SAES

Vivenne Westwood: Manifesto!

Wish I could make it to London for Vivienne Westwood’s "Art Manifesto: Active Resistance to Propaganda" at the Wallace Collection. A Manifesto at the Wallace Collection? Sounds more like the Tate Modern’s thing to me. But read on:

It sounds like a load of bollocks:

Join Vivienne Westwood as she launches her manifesto at the Wallace
Collection. Based on the premise that art gives culture and that
culture is the antidote to propaganda, Vivienne and 25 other speakers
will read aloud her manifesto and answer questions afterwards.

But at least someone is trying to think through the definitions and implications of such a manifesto:

Westwood defines Propaganda using Aldous Huxley’s words as
‘Nationalistic Idolatry, Non-Stop Distraction and Organised Lying.’ She
urges us to escape these, particularly Non-Stop Distraction, go in
search of art and become artistic freedom fighters. This involves
making the choice to become more cultured, thus more human, and to
understand the world. Our route should be to actively engage with art
and use our ethical imagination to be objective and see things as they
really are; in the process acquiring knowledge. This knowledge in turn
will make us act differently and become better citizens of the world.
In this way the Arts Manifesto is a keystone of Westwood’s wider
pre-occupations with politics and justice.

This is already a little dicey (how do we know we are seeing things as they "really are"?), but it gets worse. I’m not sure I put much stock in what Westwood thinks about contemporary art, especially as her own designs are so out there in the ether:

Westwood argues that
art must be representative; through representative human nature we gain
an imaginative insight into the general nature of things. Westwood
believes there is no progress in art and conceptual and abstract art is
today’s Emperor’s New Clothes; nothing in it except what you invent; a
subjective whim.

It actually sounds pretty reactionary, for a Manifesto.  Don’t they generally call for new forms and ideas? But I’m willing to give her the benefit of the doubt; she is an interesting and creative force herself. I would love to get her in a room and ask her to explain what she means.